New subscriptions are closed. Thanks for being awesome!

Whoopie Pies

A dessert that defies classification

choose a flavor
  • New subscriptions are closed. Thanks for being awesome!

+ free shipping!
Whoopie Pies

a handwritten note

signature marshmallow top

2 day shipping (most places)

Too small to be a cake, too big to be a cookie, and absolutely not a pie.

What is a whoopie pie?

Our whoopie pies start with a rich chocolatey cake, made with Irish cream butter and single-origin Peruvian cocoa. With a generous mound of our house vanilla marshmallow fluff sandwiched inside—It’s tender, gooey, full of chocolate flavor, and really delicious. We roll half of the whoopie pies in sprinkles, and leave the other half plain.

Weighing in at 4 ounces each, the box of six is big enough to share…or not!

Or choose a set of vegan whoopie pies, featuring locally made Miyoko's vegan butter, our well-loved single-origin Peruvian cocoa butter, and a generous mound of vegan marshmallow sandwiched inside.

A Delicious Gift to Send

A box of whoopie pies is a rad way to say congratulations, thank you, hello, or just-because. Celebrating a birthday? Just tell us in the notes when you check out and we'll include a birthday candle + your gift note!

Get the Party Started

We've made it super easy to send a gourmet gift. Here's what happens next:

  1. Choose which box of whoopie pies to send.
  2. Tell us when you'd like them delivered.
  3. Craft your note and tell us who you are sending your gift to.
  4. We'll pack up your fresh whoopie pies with your gift note inside the box and right on top, and ship it fresh right to their doorstep via 2-day delivery nationwide (most locations, some places require 3 days).

Guaranteed to be as beautiful and fresh as when they left our bakery.

Available Flavors
$31.00 & free shipping
$31.00 & free shipping

Key Ingredients

Sourced from the best places on earth

When we develop products for you to share with the people in your life, we search for the highest quality and most responsibly sourced ingredients anywhere. We believe this extra effort ensures that when you send a NotPie gift, the person receiving it will have the best possible experience.

Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla

We use organic fair-trade Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla made from hand-selected beans cultivated on the Bourbon Island of Madagascar. Cold extraction gently draws out and preserves the vanilla’s more than 250 flavor compounds, resulting in the highest quality vanilla flavor

Pasture Raised Kosher Collagen

Our traditional marshmallow is made with pasture-raised, grass-fed bovine collagen. We tested over a dozen collagens before settling on our source because of its high gel rate (Bloom) allowing us to produce a marshmallow without corn syrup.

Peruvian Cocoa Powder

Single-origin Peruvian cacao powder created from fermented and roasted cacao beans. Our cacao powder is more than 20% fat, twice the amount of regular powders, giving our cakes a dark rich chocolate flavor.